news


Is the £330 you save with a OnePlus 6 vs other Android flagships too good to be true?

OnePlus 6 smartphone

I’m thinking of getting a new smartphone so I asked for review samples of the Samsung Galaxy S9, Google Pixel 2 and OnePlus 6 to help me choose.

My current phone is the Samsung Galaxy S7, which I bought two years ago as part of a 24-month contract. That means I’m now eligible for a ‘free’ upgrade so long as I stay on the same contract. Alternatively the S7 still works just fine so I could just downgrade to a SIM-only tariff and save myself some money for a few months.

The obvious upgrade would be to move to the S9 so that’s the first one I had a look at. The most conspicuous difference from the S7 is that the ‘edge’ screen – i.e. one that wraps around the longer sides of the device – is now standard issue, while it was a premium upgrade two years ago.

You can see the difference in the photo below, which shows the S9 in the middle, my S7 on the right and the Pixel 2 XL on the left (the 1+6 hadn’t turned up before the S9 was reclaimed). You can also see that, while the overall size of the S9 is pretty much the same, they have shrunk the black bands at the top and bottom to reclaim some screen real estate.

Pixel Galaxy S x2

And that’s well worth doing because the super AMOLED screen is one of the real strengths of this phone, it seems to have higher resolution and richer colours than the others, which makes looking at it a downright pleasure.

The other big change is that the whole chassis is made of a ceramic-like glass, which feels really premium and classy but also a tad fragile and pointless since I’d be whacking a case onto it as soon as I got it out of the box anyway. On that note the Spigen case I’ve had on my S7 as contemptuously shrugged off many drops over the past couple of years.

Other positives include a distinct upgrade in general performance over my phone, surprisingly good built-in speakers (The day is my enemy by The Prodigy and Hardwired by Metallica were my chosen test tracks, on the assumption that if they could handle them they could handle anything, see below), a top camera and a face unlock feature that worked very smoothly.

 

The major negatives all concerned the software Samsung has put on the phone as part of its endless quest to be more than just a Google vassal in the smartphone space. The big one is Bigby, Samsung’s take on the AI-driven personal assistant, but there’s the usual range of Samsung app it hopes we’ll use instead of Google or third party ones.

There’s nothing conspicuously wrong with any of these, it’s just that I find myself drawn towards the alternatives, often Google ones I’ve grown accustomed to. I have to admit I haven’t warmed to smart assistants in general and still feel a bit weird talking to a device without another human being involved in the exchange, but there was nothing about Bixby that made me want to revise that position.

Moving onto the Pixel, it should be noted straight away that Google sent me the XL version, so it has a bigger screen, battery etc and is more equivalent to the S9 plus, but other than size the features are largely the same. It has a metal back and sides that feel more robust than the glass S9 and you unlock it through a fingerprint reader on the back, which is handy because your index finger naturally heads that way when you hold it.

The screen seems every bit a sharp as that of the S9 but the colours seem slightly less vivid. The speakers are just as good and, quite frankly, it was hard to tell things like the camera, performance, etc apart – they are excellent on both. I preferred the stripped-down Android interface and the syncing with various Google services is spookily complete – it even sends me relevant sports news without me even requesting it.

It was hard to find fault with the Pixel 2 XL but equally difficult to find areas in which it was conspicuously superior to the S9, which is a general problem for dilettante smartphone reviewers like me, and which brings us on to the last device in this inexpert round-up.

The 1+6, as you can see in the photo below (on the right, taken next to the Pixel when it finally turned up) it looks pretty identical to the Pixel 2 XL, the only thing worth noting in this context being the fact that this is the only size the 1+6 comes in – around a 6-inch screen. It seems to have reclaimed even more screen from the black areas and features the ‘notch’ around the top speaker and camera associated with the iPhone X.

Pixel 2 and OnePlus 6

Again the components all seem up to scratch – chip, screen, etc, and it has not one but two cameras on the back. The speakers seemed to distort a bit with Prodigy and Metallica at top volume and you get the impression many of the components, while excellent, might be one level below those of the S9 and Pixel 2 XL. OnePlus does have its own UI skin, but it seemed pretty inoffensive and it also has a fingerprint reader on the back.

The chassis is glass, like the S9, but this is rendered even more irrelevant by the fact that, in a nice touch, the 1+6 comes with a case and a screen protector thrown in. Once more it’s hard to find either a killer feature or deal-breaker with this device – it just seems solid all round, albeit with a pleasantly subtle take on haptic feedback. This has been the case with smartphones for years once the form factor matured; how do you improve on a black touchscreen rectangle with all the latest specs?

But the 1+6 does have one massive differentiator: the price. The whole OnePlus proposition from the start has been to offer a flagship device at a mass market price. The 1+6 costs £469 for the version with 64GB storage. The 64GB S9 costs £739, with the larger Plus coming in at £799 and the 64GB Pixel 2 XL will set you back £799 too.

So the big question isn’t whether or not the S9 Plus or the Pixel 2 XL are better than the 1+6, but whether they’re £330 better. The answer, surely, has to be no. There’s just no way a slightly better set of components are worth pretty much the same as a new low-end Apple iPhone. If I’m paying my own money and EE doesn’t sufficiently incentivise me to sign up for another two-year contract, then the 1+6 seems like a no-brainer and the comparison table below bolsters that view, in my opinion.

Samsung Galaxy S9 Google Pixel 2 XL OnePlus 6
Price £739 £799 £469
Dimensions 147.7 x 68.7 x 8.5mm 157.9×76.7×7.9mm 155.7×75.4×7.75mm
Screen 2960 x 1440 AMOLED 2880 x 1440 pOLED 2280 x 1080 AMOLED
Chip Exynos 9810 Snapdragon 835 Snapdragon 845
Camera 12/8MP 12/8MP 16/20/16MP
Connector USB-C USB-C USB-C
Battery 3000 mAh 3520 mAh 3300 mAh

4 comments

  1. Nikolay Stoyanov 29/06/2018 @ 5:29 pm

    “The 64GB S9 costs £739, with the larger Plus coming in at £799″

    Well, depends where one is looking. I’m sure, there would be retailers who charge even more for an S9, but a quick search on eBay will show a brand new (sealed box) Galaxy S9 handset goes for around £530-£540..That’s from a merchant with tens of thousands of completed transactions, 99+ % rating who also accepts returns, is local, etc.

    Then the 1+ proposition becomes only £60-£70 cheaper, is not water resistant doesn’t support memory expansion via micro SD, has a decent, but clearly inferior display in terms of brightness and resolution, inferior camera …. and who knows about the resale price.

    My point is Oneplus have jacked up prices enough not to be perceived as a budget alternative. Maybe streamlined software – if that’s more important to some than the above mentioned feature deficiencies.

    • Scott Bicheno Scott Bicheno 02/07/2018 @ 9:17 am

      I got all the prices from the respective vendor sites – seemed like the fairest way.

  2. Steve Brown 30/06/2018 @ 5:17 pm

    I switched to the OnePlus 6 earlier in the month and haven’t looked back, I love it. It’s fast, the facial unlock is excellent, the camera is great (much better than the Honor 8 I had previously) and the dash charge is quick.

    The lack of wireless charging is probably the only thing I can fault it for, but it’s USB-C so not as fiddly to plug in as a micro USB so it’s not a huge downside.

    I highly recommend the OnePlus 6.

  3. Stuart Williams 01/07/2018 @ 6:56 am

    They had me with this proposition too. Cheap high spec phone and the promise of two years updates. With the one plus two, they went back on their promise and stopped the updates after a year. Fingers burnt.

Leave a Reply to Stuart Williams Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Polls

Should privacy be treated as a right to protect stringently, or a commodity for users to trade for benefits?

Loading ... Loading ...